How to Find a Good SEO Consultant: Questions to Ask & Tips


Finding the right SEO consultant can be a daunting task, though it’s almost certainly a better idea than learning SEO yourself if you’re short on time. With so many options available, how can you ensure you’re hiring someone who will truly help your business grow?

In this blog post, we’ll guide you through the process of “how to find a good SEO consultant” and discuss the key traits and steps to consider. Let’s dive in!

Key Takeaways

  • Engaging an experienced SEO consultant is key for online success.
  • Look for relevant experience, up-to-date knowledge and strong communication skills when selecting a consultant.
  • Be aware of red flags such as guarantees, lack of transparency and low pricing which may indicate unprofessionalism or unethical practices.

The Importance of Hiring a Good SEO Consultant

Hiring a good SEO consultant can be a game-changer for your business. A competent SEO expert can maximize online visibility, keep you ahead of competitors, and optimize your time and resources by providing effective SEO services.

In the realm of digital marketing, a robust online presence could spell the difference between success and failure. Here are some benefits of enlisting the services of a proficient SEO consultant.

Boosting Online Visibility

SEO professionals, often found in SEO companies, assist in enhancing online visibility through optimizing websites for search engines. As SEO experts, they focus on:

  • Conducting research into your industry, target market, and competitors to determine the most relevant and popular keywords or phrases for your website
  • Working to optimize your website’s structure, content, and code
  • Helping your site appear higher in search engine results pages (SERPs)

The higher your site ranks, the more likely it is that potential customers will find your business and engage with your content.

Staying Ahead of Competitors

The rapidly evolving world of digital marketing necessitates staying a step ahead of the competition. Enlisting the help of an SEO specialist, along with other SEO specialists, can provide the competitive edge businesses need, through the application of effective SEO methodologies.

A proficient SEO consultant:

  • Keeps abreast of SEO trends and algorithm changes
  • Applies relevant strategies like technical SEO and keyword research
  • Maintains your business’s competitive edge and high search engine rankings
  • Ensures that your website remains visible to your target audience
  • Drives more traffic, leads, and sales

Saving Time and Resources

SEO can be a complex and time-consuming task. Enlisting the services of an SEO consultant enables businesses to conserve time and resources as a professional navigates the complexities of search engine optimization. Partnering with an SEO agency allows you to focus on other aspects of your business, such as product development or customer service, while the consultant works on optimizing your website for search engines.

Additionally, a good SEO consultant can help you avoid costly mistakes, such as penalties or drops in search engine rankings, making their services a valuable investment for your business.

Top Traits to Look for in an SEO Consultant

When scouting for a suitable SEO consultant, take into account attributes such as pertinent experience, current knowledge of SEO, and exemplary communication skills. These essential traits will ensure that your chosen consultant has the expertise and ability to deliver the best possible results for your business.

Below, we delve into a deeper examination of these attributes.

Relevant Experience

Relevant experience in an SEO consultant indicates a proven track record in the field, a crucial factor to consider. An extensive background in SEO enables an expert to accurately determine the necessary steps to increase a website’s search engine visibility.

By evaluating their prior work, you can determine if they have experience in your industry and if their strategies have yielded positive outcomes. This helps ensure that your SEO consultant has the necessary skills and knowledge to meet your business objectives.

Up-to-date SEO Knowledge

An SEO consultant needs to stay updated on SEO trends and algorithm shifts to guarantee the effectiveness of their strategies. Search engine algorithms are continually evolving, and by having up-to-date SEO knowledge, your consultant can ensure that your website remains optimized for search engines, leading to higher search rankings, increased organic traffic, and improved visibility for your business.

Additionally, having up-to-date SEO knowledge enables your consultant to adjust their strategies and remain one step ahead of your competitors in the ever-changing digital world.

Strong Communication Skills

Effective communication skills are paramount for an SEO consultant to articulate strategies and results efficiently. An SEO consultant should be able to clearly explain complex concepts and provide regular updates on the progress of your SEO campaign.

You can evaluate a consultant’s communication skills by asking questions during the interview process, such as how they communicate progress and results, how they handle feedback, and how they explain complex concepts. This helps ensure that you’re hiring a consultant who can effectively convey their strategies and be a valuable partner in your business’s growth.

Five Steps to Finding the Right SEO Consultant

To help you navigate the process of finding the right SEO consultant, we’ve outlined five steps to follow:

  1. Research potential candidates
  2. Seek referrals
  3. Evaluate their SEO strategies
  4. Conduct interviews
  5. Compare proposals and pricing.

Adhering to these steps guarantees the recruitment of an SEO consultant equipped with the requisite expertise, experience, and communication skills to aid your business’s online success.

Research Potential Candidates

Begin your search by researching potential SEO consultants to find those with a strong online presence and positive reviews. This can involve searching credible websites for experts specializing in search engine optimization and ranking websites. You can also search professional networks like LinkedIn Groups to identify local groups of individuals seeking an SEO expert.

Researching potential candidates provides insights into their background, proficiency, and reputation, assisting in refining your choices to find a consultant who best matches your business requirements.

Seek Referrals from Trusted Sources

A great way to find reliable and experienced quality SEO consultants is to seek referrals from trusted sources. This can include friends, colleagues, or professional networks who have had positive experiences with SEO consultants. Securing referrals from dependable sources assures that you hire a consultant with a demonstrated success record and expertise in the field.

In addition, referrals can help you avoid any negative experiences that others in your network may have encountered with certain consultants.

Evaluate Their SEO Strategies

Once you have a list of potential SEO consultants, it’s important to evaluate their SEO strategies to ensure they align with your business goals. This can involve examining their approach to:

  • Link building
  • Content creation
  • On-page optimization
  • Keyword research
  • Technical SEO

By evaluating these aspects of their strategy, you can determine if they have the expertise and experience necessary to help your business succeed in the search engine rankings.

Evaluating their strategies offers insights into their methodologies, verifies ethical practices, and helps determine if their approach aligns with your SEO goals.

Conduct Interviews

Interviewing potential SEO consultants is a crucial step in the selection process, as it allows you to assess their expertise and communication skills. During the interview, ask questions about their experience, approach to SEO, and how they stay updated on industry trends and algorithm changes.

This will help you determine if the consultant’s skills and expertise align with your business’s needs, as well as gauge their ability to effectively communicate their strategies and results.

Compare Proposals and Pricing

Finally, compare proposals and pricing from different SEO consultants to find the best fit for your budget and needs. This involves assessing the following factors:

  • Scope of work
  • Timeline
  • Cost
  • Quality of services
  • Reputation of the SEO consultant

Be mindful of any hidden costs or limitations, such as additional fees for extra services or restricted access to data and reports. By comparing proposals and pricing, you can make an informed decision and select the most suitable SEO consultant for your business.

Key Questions to Ask Potential SEO Consultants

When evaluating potential SEO consultants, posing key questions is imperative to gauge their expertise and SEO approach. Some essential questions to ask include their approach to staying updated on SEO trends, providing case studies, measuring success, link building, and handling penalties.

Below, we unpack these questions further.

How do you stay updated on SEO trends and algorithm changes?

Inquire how potential SEO consultants keep abreast of SEO trends and algorithm shifts. Staying updated is vital for an SEO consultant to guarantee the effectiveness of their strategies. Their answer should include methods such as reading industry blogs, attending conferences, and participating in online forums.

This will give you an idea of their commitment to staying current in the ever-evolving world of SEO.

Can you provide case studies or examples of successful projects?

Request potential SEO consultants to provide case studies or examples of successful projects. Evaluating their previous work helps ascertain their industry experience and the effectiveness of their strategies.

Case studies and examples provide an understanding of their methodology, creativity, and problem-solving abilities, helping you assess their overall expertise and capabilities.

How will you measure the success of our SEO campaign?

Ask potential SEO consultants about their approach to gauging the success of your SEO campaign. A comprehensive plan should incorporate metrics such as website traffic, keyword rankings, and conversions.

This will help you understand their approach to tracking progress and evaluating the efficacy of their strategies.

What is your approach to link building and content creation?

Ask potential SEO consultants about their approach to link building and content creation. Link building is an essential component of SEO, as it helps boost your website’s authority and visibility in search engine rankings.

Similarly, content creation is a critical factor in SEO, as high-quality, relevant content attracts visitors and helps improve search engine rankings. By inquiring about their approach to these aspects, you can evaluate their expertise in creating engaging and optimized content that aligns with your target audience and business goals.

How do you handle penalties or drops in search engine rankings?

Determine how potential SEO consultants address penalties or drops in search engine rankings. An experienced consultant should have a well-defined approach for dealing with such issues, which includes identifying the source of the penalty or drop, executing corrective actions, and tracking the outcomes.

This helps ensure that your SEO consultant has the necessary skills and knowledge to tackle and resolve any potential issues that may arise.

Red Flags to Watch Out for When Hiring an SEO Consultant

In your search for a suitable SEO consultant, be mindful of certain warning signs including guaranteed rankings, absence of transparency, and unusually low pricing. These warning signs can indicate a lack of professionalism or unethical practices.

Below, we delve deeper into these warning signs.

Guaranteed Rankings

Be wary of SEO consultants who guarantee rankings, as this is not a realistic promise. Due to the frequent changes in search engine algorithms, it is not feasible for SEO consultants to guarantee rankings.

Instead, look for consultants who focus on implementing effective strategies and providing measurable results.

Lack of Transparency

Avoid SEO consultants who lack transparency in their methods and communication. Transparency is essential in any business partnership, as it helps build trust and ensures you have a clear understanding of the strategies being implemented and the results being achieved.

Look for consultants who are open about their approach, progress, and any challenges they encounter.

Extremely Low Pricing

Extremely low pricing may indicate a lack of experience or quality in an SEO consultant’s services. While it’s essential to find an SEO consultant within your budget, be cautious of those offering prices that seem too good to be true.

Instead, focus on finding a consultant who provides a fair balance between cost and quality of services.


In conclusion, finding the right SEO consultant is crucial for the success of your online presence. By following the steps outlined in this blog post, considering the top traits of a good SEO consultant, and being aware of potential red flags, you can make an informed decision and select the best consultant for your business needs. Remember, a good SEO consultant can be a valuable partner in your business’s growth, so invest time and effort into finding the right fit.

Frequently Asked Questions

How do I choose a SEO consultant?

To choose an SEO consultant, be sure to ask about their experience and certifications. Consider working with someone who has experience in your industry and has had successful campaigns before. Ask for referrals from trusted business partners and consider factors such as communication, risk, pricing models, and specific goals before making a decision.

Are SEO consultants worth it?

SEO is an effective way to increase brand awareness, drive more site traffic, and grow sales revenue. Working with the right agency can help you develop the right strategy for achieving success, and while there may be an initial cost, it will be worth the investment in the long run.

What is an seo specialist?

An SEO specialist is responsible for optimizing website rankings on major search engines by utilizing various strategies, techniques and tactics. Through the increase in website visitors and a high-ranking position in results pages, SEO specialists are able to generate more leads for their clients, ultimately opening up new possibilities for growth and profit.

What are the top traits to look for in an SEO consultant?

When hiring an SEO consultant, ensure they have relevant experience, keep up-to-date with SEO knowledge and possess strong communication skills.

How can I ensure that the SEO consultant I hire has the necessary expertise and experience?

Verify the SEO consultant’s experience by asking key questions, comparing proposals and pricing, and following the advice in this blog post to make a sound decision.

Photo of author


Ted French

Digital marketer with experience in SEO, PPC & many other cool abbreviations. Happiest when analysing old websites.

Read more from Ted French